Skip to main content
Medicare Care CompareDirectories and marketplaces

Google Ads is taking credit for families your Care Compare stars already sent

A daughter checks your stars on Medicare Care Compare, searches your agency's name, taps your brand ad and calls. Google Ads claims the admission, intake writes "internet," and nobody can say whether the ads or the rating earned the patient. We give Care Compare callers their own lane, count admissions from your own records, and send the ad platforms only the patients their ads brought in, so you know which dollars fill census.

Free30 minutesNo obligation

Medicare Care Compare · what breaks

What goes wrong when families check Care Compare before they call

  1. 01

    "Our brand campaign looks like our best campaign"

    Families compare star ratings on Care Compare, then search your name and click your ad. The brand campaign collects credit for patients your rating already won, and budget drifts away from campaigns that reach families who've never heard of you.

  2. 02

    "Every call to our main number gets counted the same"

    The number CMS lists for you is often the same main line on your Google Business Profile, website and ads. Care Compare families, discharge planners, ad clicks and CNA applicants all ring it, so nobody can say which calls an ad produced, and any call conversion built on that line pays the ads for applicants and referrals.

  3. 03

    "Intake writes 'internet' and moves on"

    Intake coordinators racing to accept a referral don't stop to ask where the family looked. Without Care Compare as a set choice, your star rating's share of admissions disappears into a catch-all, and you can't weigh it against what you spend on ads.

  4. 04

    "Smart bidding is learning from patients the ads never touched"

    If every new EMR referral fires a Google Ads conversion, admissions that started on medicare.gov feed the ad signal. Bidding chases families your ads never reached, cost per admission looks better than it is, and you keep funding campaigns that aren't adding patients.

Medicare Care Compare · the fix

What changes after the fix — Medicare Care Compare

  • A real source on every admission

    Care Compare, Google Ads, Meta, hospital and physician referrals each get their own line in a monthly report built from your start-of-care and admission records.

  • Ads judged on the patients they found

    Ad inquiries carry a click ID through intake to admission, and only those admissions go back to Google Ads, and to Meta where its health-category rules allow, so bidding learns from patients the ads actually found.

  • Your star rating gets a dollar value

    With its own source, Care Compare's share of census becomes visible, so you can weigh your next dollar between ads and the quality scores behind your stars.

Medicare Care Compare · architecture

What Medicare Care Compare actually lets you hook into

Care Compare is a federal comparison site built from data CMS already holds about you. You don't log in, buy placement or add code, so tracking happens on the doors you control.

  1. 1

    A profile built from CMS records

    CMS shows your address, telephone number and ownership on Care Compare next to your quality data. The same fields are published in the Provider Data Catalog for nursing homes, home health agencies and hospices.

  2. 2

    A phone number you change through enrollment, slowly

    For home health agencies and hospices, CMS says corrections go through PECOS and iQIES (hospices file the 855A and have their MAC forward it) and can take up to six months to show. That's why we track around the listed number instead of trying to swap it.

  3. 3

    No website field to rely on

    The Provider Data Catalog files behind these profiles carry a telephone number but no website column. We still check your live profile, but we don't plan on Care Compare sending you web traffic you can tag.

  4. 4

    Star ratings on a set schedule

    Home health quality and patient survey ratings refresh quarterly; nursing homes carry overall, inspection, staffing and quality measure ratings; hospices show a family caregiver survey rating. Provider Preview Reports come before each refresh.

  5. 5

    No pixel, no click ID, no lead delivery

    Care Compare doesn't hand you leads or pass a Google or Meta click ID. A family reads your profile and calls, so attribution has to come from your intake process.

Medicare Care Compare · diagnose

Where Care Compare tracking breaks, in the order we check

Start with the phone number, because on a Care Compare profile the usual problem is one main line carrying every kind of call.

  1. 01

    Compare the number on Care Compare with your other listings

    If your profile, Google Business Profile, website and ads all share one main line, call sources can't be separated yet.

  2. 02

    Read the referral source field in your intake log or EMR

    Look for Care Compare as a choice. "Internet," "Google" and "family" usually hide it.

  3. 03

    Open your Google Ads conversion actions

    Check whether calls to the main line or every new EMR referral count as conversions, Care Compare families included.

  4. 04

    Check branded search against admissions

    A brand campaign with a low cost per admission and few families who hadn't heard of you may be harvesting people who already chose you on Care Compare.

  5. 05

    Confirm admissions carry a source

    A referral with a source and a start of care without one breaks the report at the step that pays.

Medicare Care Compare · prove

How we prove the Care Compare split holds

Tested with real calls to your listed number and your tracked ad numbers, then a closed window of admissions, not a demo account.

Source of truth

Your intake log and EMR start-of-care, hospice election and admission records with referral source and dates, checked against the profile CMS publishes for your CCN on Care Compare

  • A test call to the number on your Care Compare profile, logged once under Medicare Care Compare and absent from every ad conversion action.
  • A test call from an ad-tagged visit to a tracked number, with the click ID stored on the referral record.
  • A closed window of admissions matched by source against Google Ads, Meta and your intake log.
  • Imported admissions visible in Google Ads against the right campaigns, inside Google's 90-day click window.
  • Every Google and Meta event checked for diagnoses or other health details before go-live.
  • Rerun a month later, and again after any change to the phone number on your enrollment record.

Medicare Care Compare · free audit

What we check in the free audit

  • Compare the number on Care Compare with your other listings
  • Read the referral source field in your intake log or EMR
  • Open your Google Ads conversion actions
  • Check branded search against admissions
  • Confirm admissions carry a source

Checked against

Your intake log and EMR start-of-care, hospice election and admission records with referral source and dates, checked against the profile CMS publishes for your CCN on Care Compare

Get my free conversion tracking audit

Free30 minutesNo obligation

Medicare Care Compare · when not to buy

When you don't need this for Care Compare

Some agencies and facilities only need a better intake form.

  • If you don't run Google or Meta ads, adding Care Compare as a required intake choice will tell you what your star rating is worth for free.
  • If almost every admission comes from hospital and physician referrals and your ad budget is small, fix referral tracking first.
  • If your only worry is ad copy that quotes your star rating, check it against your current profile after each refresh yourself.
  • If your intake team already asks every caller where they looked and your ads already use tracked numbers, we'll set up the admission import and leave the rest alone.

Medicare Care Compare · what we deliver

The event map around your Care Compare profile

  • Care Compare caller logged

    Calls to the number CMS lists for you, tagged at intake with a locked "Medicare Care Compare" source and the date, kept apart from ad calls.

  • Ad-click inquiry

    A call to a tracked ad or website number, or a web form, with the Google click ID or Meta click ID saved on the referral record.

  • Referral qualified

    Insurance verified and the patient accepted for an assessment or evaluation visit, with the source carried forward.

  • Start of care or admission

    The conversion: the home health start-of-care visit, hospice election or SNF admission, confirmed in your EMR and sent back only when an ad started it. We confirm which events Meta accepts for a health advertiser before sending anything there.

  • Non-admits closed out

    Patients who go elsewhere, aren't eligible or decline are marked so ads don't keep optimizing toward them.

  • Caregiver applicants and existing families (excluded)

    CNA and nurse applicants calling about jobs, and families of current patients, are logged but never counted as new admissions.

FAQ

Medicare Care Compare questions, answered

No. The profile is built from data CMS holds about you, so there's no place for a pixel, script or tracking number. For home health agencies and hospices, CMS says phone corrections can take up to six months to appear, so we leave that line alone and put tracked numbers on your ads and website instead.

Free · 30 min

See what your star rating really sends you

Free30 minutesNo obligation