Skip to main content
ThomasnetDirectories and marketplaces

Is it Thomasnet or Google Ads that's winning your RFQs?

"We pay for Thomas and we pay for Google, and every quote request lands in the same inbox." Machine shops, fabricators and industrial cleaners hear that a lot. A Thomasnet RFI is filled in on thomasnet.com, where your tags can't run, and the Visit Website button sent buyers over with no campaign tags on the listings we checked. We label every Thomas lead at the source so Google and Meta learn only from buyers your ads brought in.

Free30 minutesNo obligation

Thomasnet · what breaks

What goes wrong when Thomasnet and paid ads share one pipeline

  1. 01

    "Google Ads takes credit for buyers who found us on Thomas"

    A buyer clicks your ad, then two weeks later finds you on Thomasnet, hits Visit Website and fills in your quote form. That's inside Google's default 30-day click window, so the ad gets the conversion, Smart Bidding treats a directory win as proof the keyword works, and you pay more for clicks that didn't close the deal.

  2. 02

    "We can't tell if the Thomas subscription pays for itself"

    Thomas RFIs, emailed drawings, web forms and calls all land in one inbox with no source on them. At renewal you're weighing a Thomas invoice against a Google invoice with no idea which produced last quarter's production work.

  3. 03

    "Google is learning from RFQs sent to ten shops at once"

    Thomas tells buyers a single project should go out as a maximum of five to 10 RFIs, so plenty of Thomas RFIs are price checks you were never going to win. If your CRM pushes every new lead back to Google or Meta, those get matched to old ad clicks by email and bidding chases more of the same.

  4. 04

    "A prototype quote and a production contract count the same"

    A one-off bracket and a recurring parts run, or a single tank cleanout and a yearly service contract, report as one identical lead, so bidding can't find the work that keeps your crews booked.

Thomasnet · the fix

What changes after the fix — Thomasnet

  • Thomas leads and ad leads reported apart

    Every RFI, call and quote form carries a source, so your Thomas program and your ad accounts are each judged on the work they actually start.

  • Only ad-started purchase orders go back to Google and Meta

    Won jobs with a stored click ID or matched email are uploaded with their PO value; Thomasnet-sourced work is filtered out before the file is built.

  • A straight answer at renewal time

    Cost per won PO from Google Ads, Meta and Thomas on one sheet, so a bigger ad budget and a higher Thomas tier can be compared honestly.

Thomasnet · architecture

What Thomasnet actually lets you hook into

Thomas documents its own analytics, not any connection to ad platforms. Here's what we found, and what we confirm on your account.

  1. 1

    Contact Supplier RFI form

    Hosted on thomasnet.com, so your Google tag, Meta Pixel and GA4 never see it. RFIs reach you through Thomas, not through your site.

  2. 2

    Visit Website button

    A plain link to the URL on your profile with no campaign tags on the listings we checked. Thomas lets you edit your website on the profile, so we confirm whether it accepts a UTM-tagged URL.

  3. 3

    Phone number on your profile

    WebTrax lists phone calls among the activity it tracks. We confirm which number it relies on before any tracking number goes on the profile.

  4. 4

    Thomas Analytics and WebTrax

    Profile views, identified buyer companies, website visits and RFI notes. Thomas says RFIs can feed marketing automation and leads can reach your CRM; the setup isn't public.

  5. 5

    No ad-platform connection

    No Google Ads, GA4, GTM or Meta integration is documented, so nothing posts won jobs to the ad platforms for you.

Thomasnet · diagnose

Where Thomasnet tracking breaks, in diagnostic order

Look for borrowed credit first. When a shop pays for Thomas and runs ads, directory buyers counted as ad buyers is a bigger problem than leads going missing.

  1. 01

    Click your own Visit Website button

    Then see how GA4 labels that session: thomasnet.com referral, or direct.

  2. 02

    Check what your Google Ads conversion counts

    If it fires on every form submit, Thomas-referred buyers are already in it.

  3. 03

    Trace how Thomas RFIs enter your CRM

    WebTrax feed, forwarded email or typed in by hand, and whether a source field is set.

  4. 04

    Check the filters on any offline upload

    Make sure Thomas-sourced deals can't be matched to an old ad click by email.

  5. 05

    Separate one-off quotes from recurring work

    Different values, so bidding chases the right jobs.

Thomasnet · prove

How we prove the split works — Thomasnet

Run on real leads from your live site and your actual Thomas RFIs, not a sandbox.

Source of truth

Your Thomasnet RFI notifications and WebTrax activity log, checked against quotes and purchase orders in your CRM or ERP

  • One quote request sent from a GCLID-tagged ad URL, then the CRM record opened to show the click ID stored.
  • One trip through your own Visit Website button, showing up as a thomasnet.com visit and not as a conversion.
  • Last month's Thomas RFIs searched for in Google Ads and Meta and found nowhere.
  • Won POs uploaded at their real dollar value, with Thomas deals and reorders filtered out.
  • Each uploaded PO traced back to its CRM record for a full, finished month.
  • The same checks rerun a month later and whenever your Thomas listing or program tier changes.

Thomasnet · free audit

What we check in the free audit

  • Click your own Visit Website button
  • Check what your Google Ads conversion counts
  • Trace how Thomas RFIs enter your CRM
  • Check the filters on any offline upload
  • Separate one-off quotes from recurring work

Checked against

Your Thomasnet RFI notifications and WebTrax activity log, checked against quotes and purchase orders in your CRM or ERP

Get my free conversion tracking audit

Free30 minutesNo obligation

Thomasnet · when not to buy

When you don't need this — Thomasnet

Plenty of Thomasnet suppliers have nothing for us to fix.

  • If you don't run Google or Meta ads, Thomas Analytics and WebTrax already report what your Thomas spend produces.
  • If your ads send traffic to a landing page Thomas buyers never reach, and only that page's form counts as a conversion, the split already exists.
  • If you win a handful of new accounts a year, a quarterly spreadsheet matching POs to lead source does the job, and we'll tell you so.
  • If you're only deciding whether to renew your Thomas program, match its RFIs against your won jobs; that's a sales-records question, not ad tracking.

Thomasnet · what we deliver

The event map from first touch to purchase order — Thomasnet

  • Arrival from your Thomasnet profile

    Labeled as Thomas referral traffic on your site, never counted as a lead or credited to an ad.

  • Quote request or tracked call on your site

    GCLID, fbclid and UTMs saved on the lead record, along with uploaded drawings or part numbers.

  • Thomasnet RFI received

    Logged in your CRM with Thomas as the source and excluded from every ad-platform upload.

  • Qualified RFQ

    Within your capabilities, materials and service area; sales reps, distributors pitching you and job seekers excluded.

  • Quote sent

    Early signal for bidding, carrying the estimated job value from your quote.

  • Purchase order won

    The one conversion that matters, valued from the PO total; reorders from accounts you already have stay out of new-customer numbers.

FAQ

Thomasnet questions, answered

You shouldn't. A Thomas RFI is submitted on thomasnet.com and didn't start with your ad click, so there's nothing honest to match it to. Log it in your CRM with Thomas as the source and keep it out of ad uploads.

Free · 30 min

Find out what Thomas and your ads each really win

Free30 minutesNo obligation